Your service business is scaling, and with the onboarding of new clients, suddenly, the operations that worked fine for a smaller portfolio are showing cracks. You want to stay on track and grow smartly—but where do you even start with benchmarking?
If you've found yourself rich in data but lacking insights, you're not alone. Many IT solutions providers track everything yet struggle to determine what "good" actually looks like for their business. Setting realistic KPI benchmarks isn't about copying industry standards and calling it a day. It's about understanding your operational reality, knowing where you stand, and creating meaningful targets that drive your business forward.
Why setting KPI benchmarks is essential for professional services
KPIs without benchmarks are just numbers on a dashboard. They might look impressive in a meeting, but they won't tell you if your utilization rate is excellent or if you're leaving money on the table.
Benchmarks transform raw metrics into insights. Here’s how:
See performance trends earlier
If your utilization is 5% below industry norms, it’s a warning sign. If it’s 20% higher, you’re burning people out. Measurable data also shows you whether you’re outperforming the competition in comparable service tiers.
Set realistic goals
Benchmarks prevent unrealistic expectations (like 100% on-time delivery every quarter) and the morale problems that come with them. Instead, you can make planning decisions that are achievable and set targets based on the operational metrics that most impact your bottom line.
Remove emotion from decision-making
Benchmarks help you justify changes, such as in staffing, price adjustments, or process improvements, based on data and not gut feelings.
Link sales promises to delivery results
Benchmarks reduce the overpromise–underdeliver trap by aligning estimates with actual delivery performance. Customers can see the delivery team meeting and even exceeding the agreed-upon standards and goals.
Factors to consider when setting KPI benchmarks
Before you dive into industry reports and start setting targets, you need to understand what makes your IT service provider unique and drives your business. Benchmarking requires nuance, as you might choose a different competitive lane than another provider, which in turn requires different KPIs.
When deciding which metrics matter most to measure, consider the following:
1. Service complexity and specialization
A provider focused on help desk and network monitoring will have vastly different benchmarks than one specializing in complex cloud migrations or cybersecurity implementations. For example, the latter should expect lower utilization rates but higher billing rates and project margins. Consider your service mix when deciding what counts as a “good” benchmark.
2. Business maturity and growth stage
A two-year-old service business with 15 clients shouldn't benchmark itself against a 20-year-old operation with 200+ enterprise accounts. An early-stage IT service provider can expect more pronounced fluctuations in metrics such as project profitability and growth as they refine service offerings and pricing models.
In contrast, an established provider would have more stable profitability metrics but would face challenges with scaling and maintaining service quality. Adapt your KPIs to be achievable for your stage in business.
3. Market and client composition
Are you serving small businesses in rural markets or Fortune 500 companies in major cities? Your client base shapes realistic benchmarks. Enterprise clients typically demand lower response times and may accept premium prices, while SMB-focused service providers often compete more on cost, requiring different efficiency metrics to maintain profitability.
Geographic market also matters. An IT service provider in a major tech hub where talent costs are a lot higher than the national average can't use the same profit margin benchmarks as a provider in a lower-cost market without adjusting expectations.
4. Historical and competitive landscape
If your average project margin is 18%, jumping straight to a 30% goal will break your team. You have to have a feasible goal while still remaining competitive. If you have improved your KPI, but are still leagues behind your competitors, then you can expect metrics like client satisfaction to suffer. Determine benchmarks that are achievable while remaining competitive.
Steps to setting realistic KPI benchmarks
Once you’ve identified contextual factors and used them to inform your decision-making, it is time to set and quantify your KPIs to drive your business forward.
1. List the core KPIs that actually matter
Not everything that can be measured should be a KPI, and piling on too many metrics dilutes focus. Start by identifying the handful of metrics that tie directly to revenue, efficiency, client satisfaction, and project delivery health.
For solutions providers, core KPIs can include:
- Utilization
- Project margin/profitability
- Average effective rate (AER)
- Average resolution time
- On-time delivery
- Billable vs non-billable time
- Rework or “quality escape” rate
- Change request volume
- Client satisfaction (CSAT/NPS)
- First-call resolution rate
- Backlog health and capacity ratios
Step 2: Collect accurate baseline data
You can't benchmark against industry standards if you don't know where you currently stand.
Gather at least 3-6 months of historical data for each KPI you've identified. If you're starting from scratch, begin tracking now and establish benchmarks once you have enough data to identify patterns rather than anomalies.
To gather data consistently, you may need to double-check or improve your tracking in your PSA, CRM, and CPQ systems. Most software can automate data tracking with the right setup.
Step 3: Analyze historical performance and industry standards
The difference between benchmarking and wishful thinking is setting a realistic target, not one so aspirational that it remains a pipedream.
First, review your performance trends with the data you’ve been collecting. Ask questions that reveal if your metrics are improving or declining and why. If your utilization rate has dropped from 75% to 65% over the past six months, you need to understand why before setting a target of 80%.
Next, research relevant industry data. Look for benchmarks from service providers similar to yours in size, market, and service focus. A KPI means nothing if that data includes massive enterprise providers whose operations look nothing like yours. Many PSA and RMM software analytics now include anonymized peer comparison data. Additionally, major software providers such as ConnectWise and Datto publish industry reports that offer a wealth of information.
Step 4: Quantify realistic targets
Put a number next to each of your KPIs. This can be a specific stat or a range. Some providers use the 70/20/10 framework for outlining their metrics. This framework suggests that:
- 70% of your benchmarks should be "stretch but achievable:” these are targets that require effort but are within reach of your current trajectory
- 20% should be "aspirational:” these targets are industry-leading and might take years to achieve
- 10% should be "maintain current performance:” these are where you’re already meeting a good standard and the goal is simply not to slip backwards
Document a plan to meet the targets, so it helps formalize the goal:
- The timeframe for achieving it
- Who owns responsibility for the metric
- What specific actions or initiatives will drive improvement
- The resources required to hit the target
If needed, you can always benchmark by service category. This works well in cases like when your M365 rollout team can hit upper-range benchmarks but your Azure migration team cannot.
Step 5: Review and adjust benchmarks regularly
Markets shift, your business evolves, and external factors like economic conditions and technology changes impact what's realistic. Treat your benchmarks as living targets, not carved-in-stone commandments.
Schedule reviews where you:
- Assess progress toward each benchmark
- Identify obstacles and resource constraints affecting performance
- Adjust targets if underlying business conditions have materially changed
-
Celebrate wins when you hit or exceed benchmarks
If you consistently miss targets by wide margins, your benchmarks aren't realistic and can even demoralize the team. If you consistently exceed them without effort, they're not driving improvement. Ultimately, benchmarks aren’t about chasing perfection, but creating a feedback loop that helps you improve over time.
Common KPIs for professional services
Below are common KPIs used across professional services. These align closely with what solutions providers track.
1. Utilization rate
Your utilization rate measures the percentage of time your team spends on billable client work versus administrative tasks, training, and downtime. Though this is one of the most important metrics, it is often forgotten, even though labor is typically a service provider’s highest cost.
Industry benchmark: 70-80% billable utilization
If your technicians have a low utilization rate, then you’re either overstaffed, inefficient, or bogging the team down with too much administrative work. If your utilization is too high, then it can lead to burnout and potential quality issues.
2. Profit margin
Your gross profit margin measures revenue minus cost of goods sold (COGS). This is what's left after you pay for the direct costs of delivering your services, but before accounting for overhead and operating expenses.
Industry benchmark: 8-18% profit margin
Measuring this ensures you don’t accidentally eat into your margins. Without keeping track of gross profit margin, you might issue more contracts that don’t account for the actual service demands, suffer from paying for more licenses and tools than you’re billing for, and underprice your delivery when you need more labor hours than estimated.
3. On-time project delivery
This tracks how often you meet your promised delivery dates, which directly impacts client trust and your ability to manage resources effectively.
Industry benchmark: 80-90% on-time delivery, with 90%+ as exemplary
Late projects create cascading problems, such as frustrated clients, margin erosion from extended labor, and resource conflicts as your pipeline backs up. Typically, it’s not an execution issue, but the problem stems from inaccurate scoping. If you fix scoping accuracy or invest in better tools like CPQs, then on-time delivery almost always improves.
4. Average resolution time
This measures how long it takes your team to fully resolve client issues from the moment a ticket is opened to its closure.
Industry benchmark: 30 min - 2 hours resolution time, depending
Having an industry-wide benchmark for this is a bit misleading. As mentioned earlier, the types of services you specialize in will affect this metric, and what is good for one company might be a poor benchmark for another. The more complex services you deal with, the more likely you are to need a longer resolution time. Patching a cybersecurity issue typically takes longer than a simple account management request.
Breaking out your resolution times by ticket type is often more revealing. For example:
- Password resets and simple issues: <15 minutes
- Standard technical issues: 2–4 hours
- Complex problems or investigations: 1–3 days
- Project-related work: tracked separately
Then gauge how your KPIs trend across ticket priority and severity categories to get a more accurate picture of how your company is doing.
5. Monthly recurring revenue (MRR)
MRR growth measures how fast your predictable, recurring revenue stream is expanding month over month. It measures the revenue generated from retainers, subscriptions, upsells, and recurring services.
Industry benchmark: 4-8% recurring revenue
It represents contracted revenue you can count on, making it easier to forecast, hire, and invest in your business confidently. If growth is low or negative, then it would indicate a churn problem. A healthy rate indicates winning new clients, retaining existing clients, and expanding services within current customers.
How to use KPI benchmarks to drive continuous improvement
Continuing to use KPIs to move the needle for your business is how you can see significant improvements. Use the benchmarks to create accountability loops. If every KPI has an owner, then someone will always remain responsible for improving it and implementing a plan of action when it dips.
Connect each benchmark to a specific operational change or plan, so the team is clear on how to maintain the goal. Then you can compete against yourself by tracking your company’s improvement over time. As you continually improve where your company shines, you can also focus your energy on areas that you notice are struggling or showing stagnant growth.
The role of tools and technology in tracking benchmarks
Manual data entry is error-prone, time-consuming, and hard to maintain consistently as your business grows. The right tools make benchmarking sustainable by doing the hard work for you:
CPQ software like ScopeStack helps solutions providers scope projects more accurately, leading to better delivery benchmarks and fewer scope creep incidents that destroy profitability.
PSA platforms automatically track time, projects, and profitability. They often can calculate utilization, project margins, and delivery metrics without manual intervention.
Project management and ticketing platforms can capture real-time data, giving you insights into ticket management, response times, change requests, and other metrics that inform your benchmarks.
Financial systems integrated with your PSA ensure your profitability calculations include all costs, giving you an accurate picture of your margins.
The key is integration. Tools that don't talk to each other create data silos that make benchmarking harder, not easier. Providers that integrate CPQ, PSA, PM, and billing systems create a closed-loop KPI system where estimates, delivery, and financial outcomes sync automatically. ScopeStack starts that process strong, with a platform that integrates with your PSA and ticketing systems.
Setting realistic KPI benchmarks isn't about chasing arbitrary industry standards or making your dashboards look impressive. It's about understanding where your IT service company actually stands, identifying meaningful targets that drive improvement, and creating the accountability structures to hit those targets consistently.
Ready to set your business on the right track? Discover how ScopeStack elevates the discovery and scope process—book a demo today.
You may also like: