Many IT service providers and MSPs build their businesses on technical expertise—configuring networks, implementing software, and troubleshooting complex systems. But long-term success requires more than technical know-how; it demands a clear strategy for measuring and improving profitability.
Profitability isn't just about charging more than your costs. It’s about optimizing service delivery, managing costs effectively, and ensuring each engagement contributes to the bottom line. That’s where profitability KPIs come in. By tracking the right metrics, you gain the visibility needed to identify inefficiencies, uncover growth opportunities, and drive sustainable profitability.
The importance of profitability in professional services
Profitability isn’t just about surplus revenue. It’s a critical indicator of sustainable business practices, operational efficiency, and overall client satisfaction. When your projects consistently deliver strong margins, you’re likely pricing correctly, deploying the right resources, and managing projects effectively.
Many IT service providers make the mistake of focusing solely on revenue growth. While increasing your top line feels good, it doesn't always translate to higher profits. A company generating $5 million in revenue with 30% profit margins is more valuable than one bringing in $10 million with only 10% margins. Despite half the revenue, the former makes $1.5 million in profit versus $1 million for the latter.
Poor profitability might be an early sign of deeper issues, such as inadequate project scoping that leads to frequent overruns or poor resource allocation. If inefficiencies persist, they can affect profits and limit growth capacity.
Conversely, minor improvements in profitability metrics compound over time. A 5% increase in billable utilization or a 3% improvement in project margin might seem small. However, across an entire team and over a whole year, these small gains can translate to hundreds of thousands in additional profit without requiring a single new client.
That’s why profitability is also a barometer of overall business health. To keep a business healthy, you need to track the right profitability KPIs.
KPIs to measure professional services capability
Measuring the correct group of KPIs when tracking IT service profitability creates a framework that you can use to assess important questions such as:
- Which types of projects to pursue and which to avoid
- When to hire additional staff versus optimizing existing resources
- How to price your services competitively while maintaining healthy margins
- Where inefficiencies or value leaks exist in your delivery processes
Below are helpful KPIs when looking to get the complete picture of your IT service company’s financial well-being:
1. Gross margin
Gross margin is the percentage of revenue after deducting the direct cost of delivering your services. For IT providers, this often includes technician labor, software licensing fees, contractor costs, and other direct expenses.
How it’s calculated: Gross margin = (Revenue - Cost of services) / Revenue × 100%
Why it matters: This foundational metric reveals how efficiently you deliver services and whether your pricing strategy aligns with your cost structure. If your gross margin is thin, you may be underpricing services or overspending on resource procurement. Since IT service providers bill more for labor than actual products, a good gross margin is between 50-70%, depending on the service mix and business model.
If certain services consistently show below-average margins, you can raise prices, reduce delivery costs, or reconsider offering them.
Example: An MSP charges $150/hour for network configuration services. The direct labor cost (including benefits) for the engineer performing this work is $65/hour, plus $10/hour in software licensing costs allocated to this service. The gross margin would be: ($150 - $75) / $150 × 100% = 50%.
2. Project profitability
Project profitability measures the actual profit generated by individual projects compared to what was estimated.
How it’s calculated: Project profitability = (Actual revenue - Actual costs) / Actual revenue × 100%
Why it matters: This metric helps identify which projects consistently deliver the highest returns and which tend to underperform financially. You can use this information to refine your offerings, adjust pricing, or optimize processes to address your weak spots.
Example: Your MSP implemented a new enterprise backup solution for a healthcare client. The project was quoted at $45,000 with estimated costs of $27,000, targeting a 40% margin. However, due to unexpected compatibility issues with legacy systems, the actual costs ballooned to $33,000. The actual project profitability was: ($45,000 - $33,000) / $45,000 × 100% = 26.7% — significantly below target.
3. Utilization rate
Utilization rate measures the percentage of total working hours spent on billable client tasks.
How it’s calculated: Utilization rate = Billable hours / Available hours × 100%
Why it matters: IT service companies often spend the most on labor costs, so optimizing this metric makes a company more profitable. A low utilization rate can point to inefficiencies like poor scheduling, underutilizing a team member, or an overstaffed team.
Conversely, extremely high utilization rates may indicate burnout risks or inadequate staffing for future work. Set target utilization rates based on the role, aiming for 75-85% for technical consultants and engineers and a lower rate for management.
Example: A senior systems engineer has 160 available monthly hours (40 hours/week × 4 weeks). After accounting for internal meetings, training, and administrative tasks, she logs 128 billable hours. Her utilization rate is: 128 / 160 × 100% = 80%.
4. Realization rate
Realization rate takes utilization one step further by examining what portion of your billed hours actually gets collected as revenue. Even if you bill for hours, you might discount or write some off due to scope disputes, client dissatisfaction, or other reasons.
How its calculated: Realization rate = Collected billable revenue / Billable hours × 100%
Why it matters: The realization rate highlights your ability to turn billable work into actual dollars. Low realization rates suggest you’re not taking in as much money as possible due to writing off hours, scope creep, or bad billing processes. This metric often reveals disconnects between project delivery and financial operations.
Example: Your technical team recorded 250 hours on a cloud migration project. However, due to some rework and internal debates about what fell within the scope, only 215 hours were ultimately billed to the client. The realization rate would be 215 / 250 × 100% = 86%.
5. Average revenue per client (ARPC)
ARPC measures the average revenue generated from each client over a specific period (usually monthly or annually). This KPI is especially relevant if you manage a broad portfolio of customers and want to gauge each customer's average financial contribution.
How it’s calculated: ARPC = Total revenue / Number of active clients
Why it matters: This metric helps you understand the health of your client portfolio and identify growth opportunities. Low ARPC might indicate that you're spending too much time managing numerous small clients rather than pursuing larger, more profitable relationships.
Example: An MSP generates $2.4 million in annual revenue across 40 active clients. Their ARPC is: $2,400,000 / 40 = $60,000 per client annually, or $5,000 monthly.
6. Employee cost-to-revenue percentage
Also known as the payroll-to-revenue ratio, it compares the total cost of your technical staff (salaries, benefits, bonuses, etc.) to the revenue they generate. It reveals how effectively you’re utilizing your workforce relative to revenue creation.
How it’s calculated: Employee cost-to-revenue ratio = Total employee costs / Total revenue × 100%
Why it matters: For IT services and managed services companies, labor is typically the largest expense category. This metric helps ensure your team generates sufficient revenue to justify their cost and contribute to profitability. Due to the service industry’s reliance on skilled labor, the employee cost-to-revenue ratio in this area is higher than in other sectors. Aim for a ratio between 40-60%. If your ratio is over 60%, you may be overstaffed or underpriced.
Example: Your MSP has a technical team with total compensation costs of $1.2 million annually. If this team generates $2.5 million in services revenue, the employee cost-to-revenue ratio would be: $1,200,000 / $2,500,000 × 100% = 48%.
7. Project overrun percentage
Project overrun percentage measures how frequently your projects exceed their estimated hours or costs.
How it’s calculated: Project overrun percentage = (Actual hours - Estimated hours) / Estimated hours × 100%
Why it matters: This metric helps identify systemic issues in your estimation process or project management approach. Project overruns can reduce profitability and cause disgruntled clients, so it is important to know if they occur frequently.
Example: Your team estimated that a server migration would take 60 hours, but it actually took 72 hours to complete. The project overrun percentage would be: (72 - 60) / 60 × 100% = 20%.
8. Client acquisition cost
Client acquisition cost (CAC) measures the amount spent on marketing and sales to acquire a new client.
How it’s calculated: CAC = Total sales & Marketing expenses / Number of new clients acquired
Why it matters: While not a direct profitability metric, CAC influences how quickly new clients become profitable. High acquisition costs require longer client relationships to reach profitability. Compare the metric to client lifetime value to ensure you make smart choices about growing the business. Also, compare CAC across different marketing channels to optimize your acquisition strategy.
Example: Your MSP spent $120,000 on marketing and sales activities in Q2, resulting in 8 new client acquisitions. The CAC would be: $120,000 / 8 = $15,000 per new client.
How to improve these KPIs to maximize profitability
Once you consistently measure and track your KPIs, it’s essential to understand how to turn this data into action. Improving poorly performing KPIs will enhance your company’s profitability.
1. Refine project scoping
One of the biggest issues for professional services firms is underestimating the scope of a project. Scope creep can rapidly inflate costs due to overly optimistic timelines, unfamiliar service niches, or client-driven changes. Implementing rigorous change management processes can improve project profitability and realization rates. Document the initial project scope, educate clients on the change request process, and ensure all additional work is approved and billed appropriately.
2. Optimize resource allocation
Get the right people on the best task for their skills at optimal scheduled times. Use resource management software that integrates with your project management platform. Real-time dashboards let you see resource capacity and upcoming availability. This helps in adjusting workloads dynamically so no one is idle or overburdened. Create service delivery models that leverage senior resources for critical design and architecture work while using more junior staff for implementation and support tasks.
3. Focus on client selection and retention
Not all clients are equally profitable. Use your profitability metrics to identify the characteristics of your most profitable client relationships and focus business development efforts on similar prospects. Simultaneously, develop strategies to improve or transition away from consistently unprofitable relationships.
4. Invest in staff development
High turnover and a lack of specialized skills can result in subpar project delivery and inflated labor costs. Mistakes can impact a realization rate if you feel compelled to comp hours for a client. Similarly, underqualified or strained employees may make more mistakes, such as improperly scoping projects. Allocate some of the budget for certifications and ongoing training to deepen your team’s expertise. Consider a mentorship program where senior engineers or consultants guide junior staff. Skilled employees can handle more tasks independently, increasing overall productivity and utilization.
5. Adjust pricing
If you consistently see tight margins, your pricing may not align with the market value of your services. Underpricing reduces profit and can distort client expectations regarding effort and costs. Conduct periodic competitor analyses to see how similar services are priced, then make any necessary changes.
The role of technology in tracking KPIs
Manually tracking these complex metrics across numerous projects and clients is nearly impossible. The right technology stack is essential for accurate measurement and actionable insights. Here is how technology can ease the burden of tracking this data:
Automated data capture
By automating data capture, these tools drastically reduce human error and eliminate the need to dig into multiple platforms for reporting metrics. PSA platforms integrate time tracking, project management, and billing functions to provide real-time visibility into profitability metrics. Let the platform capture the data so you only need to review it.
Business intelligence and data visualization
BI tools create visual dashboards of your key profitability metrics, which help translate raw data into actionable insights. Some programs can transform complex data into clear visualizations highlighting trends and opportunities. Real-time dashboards can also help you quickly identify red flags, such as a project that’s starting to show signs of overruns.
CPQ solutions for accurate estimations
Configure, price, and quote (CPQ) software, like ScopeStack, can improve your estimation accuracy by standardizing pricing models and incorporating historical project data. These tools reduce the risk of under-quoting and help maintain consistent margins across your service offerings.
ScopeStack ensures you have the most accurate figures from day one, leading to higher project profitability and accurate revenue forecasts. For services businesses operating on thin margins, where even minor estimation errors can eliminate profitability, CPQ solutions represent a convenience and a competitive advantage that enables confident pricing, improved resource planning, and, ultimately, more predictable financial performance.
Achieving and maintaining profitability in professional services requires a proactive, data-driven approach. By honing in on core KPIs, you can identify inefficiencies, optimize resource allocation, refine pricing strategies, and ultimately maximize profitability. Remember that the goal isn't perfect metrics—it's better decisions that sustain profitability.
If you’d like to learn more about how a CPQ can improve your company’s profitability, please get in touch today.
You may also like: